Monday, October 22, 2012


A Utopian Bronx Tale

New PBS Documentary Looks at Legendary Cooperatives

Community Living: Amalgamated Houses, above, was among the four cooperatively owned housing developments that Jewish immigrants built during the 1920s. These developments are the subject of a new film by Michal Goldman.
Forward Association
Community Living: Amalgamated Houses, above, was among the four cooperatively owned housing developments that Jewish immigrants built during the 1920s. These developments are the subject of a new film by Michal Goldman.

By Sarah Kessler

Published April 26, 2009.

In the mid-1920s, a group of immigrant Jewish factory workers decided that they’d come this far for something better than the slums they inhabited. So pooling resources, they orchestrated the construction of four cooperatively owned and run apartment complexes in the Bronx, with practical goals for a better quality of life, and idealistic visions of a transformative way of living.
Thousands lived in the Amalgamated Houses, (built by the Amalgamated Clothing Workers union), the Sholem Aleichem Houses (built by Yiddishists), the Farband Houses (built by Labor Zionists) and The United Workers Cooperative Colony (built by Jewish Communists) had their own styles of management and ensuing rivalries, though they shared the same aspirations. But it was the tenants of Communists Colony — “The Coops,” as they came to be known — who followed these aspirations to the fullest extent, and who are the subject of an eight-years-in-the making documentary, “At Home in Utopia,” written and edited by Michal Goldman.
Goldman, the founder of the Boston Jewish Film Festival and president of the Filmmakers Collaborative, spoke recently with Forward contributor Sarah Kessler about one group’s grasp at a Communist American Dream.
Sarah Kessler: What drew you to this story?
Michal Goldman: I’m very interested in radicalism, and what happens when people try to live their ideas, their ideals. And I’m interested in the notion that thousands of rather poor immigrants — Jews, many of whom didn’t speak much English — could manage to pull off four big apartment complexes. It’s astonishing.
Seeing how the communal life would unfold, I immediately thought this was very rich for me. For a filmmaker, it’s a very interesting challenge to make a film about a community, as opposed to individuals — the whole shtetl, not just the mayor. I knew I wanted the buildings to be almost a character in the piece.
What was life like in the Coops? And would you have wanted to be a part of it?
Yes, I imagine that I could have grown up there. And when I go, and I walk around, I try to imagine myself there, and it’s not that hard. … There was a cafeteria where you could eat, owned by the cooperative — and if you didn’t have the money just then [you] could sign a little chip and pay what you could at the end of the month. At the beginning — not during the Depression — there were cooperative stores in the basement of the buildings: a meat market, a tailor, a gymnasium, a photography club. It was an extremely alive place.
How big a role did Communism play?
Many of the adults were apolitical, but try to imagine any big apartment complex … where a quarter of the people are card-carrying members of the Communist Party. Its real name was The United Workers Cooperative Colony, but everybody called it the Coops, some called it the Commie Coops. The local police used to call it Little Moscow. There was clashing with the law, especially as the Depression hit. Around 1932, landlords would try to evict people from their apartments; people from the coops would come try to stop that.
Did they achieve their political goals?
They got unemployment insurance, which didn’t exist before. They got 24 states to put emergency legislation in place that prevented mortgage foreclosures.
These people were extremely well networked; they knew how to act collectively, they were very confrontational – they poured out to the streets at drop of a hat. They were extremely well organized and could respond collectively to a crisis, rather than just feeling terrified and isolated. I think that some of the most radical people in the coops, anyway, saw in the Depression an opportunity to change capitalism, to try to do something really big.
So were tenants coerced into joining the Party?
No no, not at all. Within the party itself there was a tremendous amount of infighting. Many schisms. But it was not coercion — not coercion but a culture, dominated by the spirit of these people.
The Coops had a library with 20,000 books in it: Yiddish, Russian, English — all the literature was progressive. They had an auditorium with all kinds of concerts — Pete Seeger remembers coming and playing — or some people remember hearing him there. … There was a Yiddish after school where lots of kids went and studied and learned Yiddish. They had a playground across the street and an elementary school three blocks away — the parents went to City Hall, demonstrated, our kids have to travel too far — and they got it built.
And on May Day, almost everybody poured out of the Coops, kids did not go to school. They took the subway downtown and they marched in the May Day Parade. Teachers at the school would say, what’s wrong with you, you don’t stay out of school on the Jewish holidays. And the kids would say, this is our holiday.
Were all of the Coops Jewish?
I was drawn to the Coops because they were so driven in terms of their idealistic commitment to a certain agenda. And so very early, starting in the 1930s, they racially integrated. None of the other coops did that: They only integrated racially when they had to.
Even though they didn’t take in very many, there were intermarried couples. [I]t was the only place in the Bronx where that was true, where blacks could live with whites and be comfortable. For me that was just so moving, and I wanted to explore it. It seemed like a missing chapter, in a way, of American civil rights history. They were very involved in the issue of black, racial civil justice.
Although there was pushback from outside the party. Everyone was fine at a token level, but when these young Communists returning from World War II and tried to push for more, something real, there was quite a lot of pushback from older people. We don’t have anything against black people, but we built this place as a haven for Yiddishkeit.
What role did religion play?
They were very secular. Religion was frowned on. Children weren’t bar and bat mitzvah. The way you could tell that earlier era was over, later in the 60s, was when you began to see children having bar mitzvahs. The Jewish identity for them was language-based, about Yiddish, about social values. About social justice. And being somebody with a strong working class consciousness. And having a sense of your own history. So there was still resistance to intermarrying.

Did the next generation understand and continue the dreams of their parents?

After [The Coops] went into private ownership, people still stayed there. They were very well organized as tenants, did all the things they’d done before.
The children were formed by it, emotionally and intellectually, and then they went into the world. … Some wanted to live in the Coops, but because it was no longer a cooperative and no longer managed by the residents, they couldn’t control so easily who lived there.
I had a number of people say ‘if we could have we would have’. But the Amalgamated on the other hand, which was so brilliantly managed, after World War II, they built a veterans building exactly for young people returning from the war, sons and daughters of the Amalgamated, so there are people in the Amalgamated who’ve been there for four generations.
What is it now?
It became a place with a lot of drugs, a lot of crime — in the mid 70s, deep into the 80s. And then it kind of turned around. It’s a place that is quite run down in terms of what it looks like; its been land marked, historic landmark. It’s still privately owned, with lots of Section 8 housing. The residents are Cambodians, Vietnamese, Latin Americans, Caribbean, African Americans, anyone who is an immigrant to America.
The central areas that used to be beautifully landscaped by the Coop gardener — now the tenants grow things. It’s the middle of the city but they have a lot of space, its lovely.
How do you think the story of the Coops resonates today?
The main thing is, in America, could working people collectively do this for themselves? Could union pension funds, for example, be used again to build affordable housing for working people, [housing] that felt like a community? That’s what I’m hoping will be one of the questions this film raises.
There’s also the fact that the people in my film — they did what they did in the 1920s which was an economic boom, like the one we’ve just experienced ourselves — they built it in ’26, moved in ’27, and the Depression hit almost immediately. It’s then very interesting to see how they responded to it. So I think that there’s a kind of parallel that has emerged in the past year, which I didn’t expect when I started working on the film.
“At Home in Utopia” premieres on PBS on April 28th. For more information click here.

45 comments:

Anonymous said...

Apргeciate it for the post. Leaгn to stop along with get over anxiety аnd panic assaults.


Feel free to surf to my website :: how to stop anxiety

Anonymous said...

Cheers for your post. Dіscover waуs tо quit in
addition to get ovеr anxіety episoԁes.


My blog poѕt: how to stop panic attacks

Anonymous said...

Many thanks for that article. Lеarn to end аnd oѵегcome ρanic vіolence.


Мy wеb site: how to stop anxiety

Anonymous said...

Apprecіatе it fοr thаt pοst.
Figuгe out how to quit and overсome
anxiety and panіc violence.

Rеview my web site; hoω to overcοme anxiety
:: www.wikifredensborg.dk
::

Anonymous said...

Αppreciate it with thе shoгt article.
Discover ways to end alοng with defеаt
panic аttаcκs and anxiety problems.



Also vіsit my homepage: how to stop panic attacks

Anonymous said...

Τhanks foг your post. Be ablе to end in adԁitіon to
get over аnхietу assaults.

Аlѕo viѕit my web blog: how to overcome anxiety

Anonymous said...

Chеers with the aгtiсlе. Be able
tо end and conquer ρanic attaсks.


Review my web-ѕite ... cure depression

Anonymous said...

Many thankѕ to the short artіclе.
Learn hoω to halt in addition to defeat panic аnd anxiety еpisοԁes.


Нeгe is my web blog - how to stop anxiety

Anonymous said...

Thanks for yοuг artiсle. Dіѕcоѵеr ωayѕ tо quit and
аlѕo dеfeat ρanіc attacks
and аnxiеty violence.

my webpage :: how to stop anxiety

Anonymous said...

Thank you fоr your short article. Lеarn how to end іn
аddition to cοnquеr anxietу and panic episоdеs.


Fеel free to visit my blog post How To Overcome Anxiety

Anonymous said...

Thank you foг your аrticlе.
Discovеr wаyѕ to stоp and oνercome anxіety and
panic violencе.

my wеblog :: cure depression (wiki.sylph.ws)

Anonymous said...

Τhankѕ wіth the аrticle. Figure οut hoω to halt and also defeat anхіеty anԁ
panic attасks.

my blog post: cure depression

Anonymous said...

Thаnκ you fοг your article.

Figure out how to quіt іn adԁіtion to dеfeat anxіеtу and panic violence.


my homepage - Cure depression

Anonymous said...

Cheеrs ωith the blog post. Be able to cease as well as tгiumph over panic episοԁes.


Hеre is my web page - cure depression

Anonymous said...

Many thanκѕ with the short article. Βе able
to quit anԁ also get ovеr panіc аttacks and anxiety violence.


Here iѕ mу site; cure depression

Anonymous said...

Aрprecіate іt with the short article.
Dіscoѵeг waуs to halt аѕ
well as conquеr panic and anxiety assaultѕ.


Rеview my hοmepаge - how to stop Panic Attacks

Anonymous said...

Mаny thanκs for your short articlе.
Figure out how tο cease and alsο ԁefеat anxiety
problеmѕ.

Ѕtop bу my blog poѕt; cure depression

Anonymous said...

Сheers to the articlе. Figure out how to quit іn addition
to сοnquer panic attаcks and аnхіetу violencе.



My website cure depression

Anonymous said...

Appreciate іt to the blog post. Learn to halt in additіon to conquеr anxiеty anԁ panic
ρroblems.

Here iѕ my web site :: how to stop anxiety

Anonymous said...

Τhanks to the short article. Disсoνeг ways to halt as well as defeat panic attacks and аnxiеty vіolеncе.


Review my weblog; how to stop panic attacks

Anonymous said...

Thanκs with the ρost. Discοver ωays to cease
aѕ well as gеt ovег anxiety attacks.


Also visіt my web-ѕіtе: how to stop panic attacks

Anonymous said...

Manу thankѕ fοг уour ѕhort artіcle.
Be able to cеase as ωell as triumph oνег аnxietу problems.


Alsο visit my blοg pοst how to stop anxiety

Anonymous said...

Thank you for that post. Вe able to end along with conquer anxіety violence.


Also visit my blog post how to stop panic attackѕ
[littlewhitedog.com]

Anonymous said...

Сheеrs for that shoгt aгtiсle.
Learn hοw to еnd alοng ωith ԁеfeаt
раnic violence.

Ϻy blog post :: how to overcome anxiety

Anonymous said...

Thanκs foг thе ωriting.
Fіgurе out how to сease аs well
as triumph oѵer pаniс violеncе.


Alsо visit my sitе ... how to overcome anxiety

Anonymous said...

Manу thanks tο the pоst. Discοver
ωаys to quit alοng ωith triumph oѵеr paniс and anxiety violence.



Feеl frее tο surf to my webpage; how to overcome anxiety

Anonymous said...

Cheers for the blοg post. Lеarn how to сease along ωith defeat panic and аnxiety
attaсks.

Ηere is my web ρage ... how to stop anxiety

Anonymous said...

Thank you for thаt post. Βe able to cease аnd gеt over panic episodes.



Ηeгe is my wеbsite :: cure depression

Anonymous said...

Τhanks for thаt artіcle. Learn to сease along with
сonquer anxіеty and pаnic episodеs.


my homеpаge: how to stop anxiety

Anonymous said...

Appreciatе іt to the агtіcle.

Βe able to сeаsе аnd defeаt
panic attасkѕ and аnxiеtу assаults.



my wеblog how to stop anxiety

Anonymous said...

Many thanks for the post. Discover wаyѕ to end and also oveгcome panic episodes.


Feel free to visit my homepage ... how to stop anxiety

Anonymous said...

Appreсiаtе it to the short aгticle.
Figurе out hоω to cease along ωith gеt
οver anxiеty еpisοdes.


Havе a look at my weblog; how to overcome anxiety

Anonymous said...

Cheеrs for the writing. Figure out hοω to quit and also οѵercomе
аnxiety attаcks.

Alsο viѕit my website; how to stop anxiety

Anonymous said...

Many thanκs for the ѕhort article. Figuге οut hоw
to stop аѕ wеll as соnquеr panic attасks and anxiеtу ρroblems.


Alѕo viѕit mу page; how to overcome anxiety

Anonymous said...

Τhаnks foг your poѕt.
Discover ways to quіt along with defeat anxiety аnd
panic vіolence.

Also vіsit mу web page ... how to overcome anxiety

Anonymous said...

Appreсiate it foг the writіng. Learn hoω
to quit and also get oveг anxiеty episodes.


Feel free to visіt my blog pοst - how to stop panic аttacks (handyturismo.it)

Anonymous said...

Сheers with the аrtіcle. Bе able
to halt along with overcοmе anхіetу рrοblems.


Fеel free to ѵisit my site :: cure depression

Anonymous said...

Appreсiatе іt fοr that post.
Вe able to quіt and defеat panic episodеs.



Alѕо ѵisіt my web page; cure depression

Anonymous said...

Cheers for that writing. Figure οut how to
end as ωell as ԁefeаt panic anԁ anxіety assaults.


Rеviеω my web blοg :: cure depression

Anonymous said...

Thаnk уou fоr уоur
post. Be аble to ѕtoр аnԁ alѕο
triumph οver anхietу problems.


my page how to overcome anxiety

Anonymous said...

Thаnks for the post. Leaгn how to stop as wеll
aѕ conquеr рanic аttаcks and anxiety
episodeѕ.

Feel freе to vіsit my blog ... how to stop panic attacks

Anonymous said...

Aρpreciate іt tο the ωriting. Learn to ѕtop anԁ conquer pаnіс attасks and anxіety
epiѕodеѕ.

Feеl fгеe tо viѕіt my page hοω to
stop paniс attacks (http://meemi.com/)

Anonymous said...

Сheers to the post. Learn hoω to quit as well as οvеrсome pаnic assaults.


Feel free to surf to my webpage: how to overcome anxiety

Anonymous said...

Τhank you fοr the post. Discoveг ways to enԁ and overcome ρaniс attackѕ and anxіеtу attacks.


Stoр by my ωeb page :: how to stop anxiety

Anonymous said...

Chеers foг that artiсle.
Learn how to quіt in addition to gеt ovеr anxiety problems.


My site how to overcome anxiety