The city’s lack of affordable housing actually is a “good sign” of a
vibrant economy, Mayor Bloomberg said Friday in remarks that touched off
fresh criticism that he is out of touch.
In his weekly radio appearance on WOR-AM, Bloomberg said housing is
scarce because “as fast as we build, more people want to live here.”
PHOTOS: WORLD’S MOST EXPENSIVE REAL ESTATE
He added that market forces — developers building housing to meet the demand — would help to address that need.
“Somebody said that there’s not enough housing. That’s a good sign,” Bloomberg said.
PHOTOS: DAILY NEWS/MARIST POLL: CHARTING BLOOMBERG FATIGUE
“It doesn’t mean it isn’t a problem, but there are no vacancies. That
will bring in investment, for people to build for all income levels,
different kinds of housing,” he said.
AP Photo/Bebeto Matthews
Bronxdale Houses, childhood home for Sonia Sotomayor, remains a low-income residential community in Bronx.
“In cities, if you want to have lots of vacancies where everybody could easily find a place, you don’t have a good economy.”
PHOTOS: NYC'S MOST ROMANTIC REAL ESTATE
He added that all that demand is great for business, and it makes him
popular with construction workers and developers. “When I march by in a
parade, I get a lot of waves. Construction workers should be very happy.
Developers should be very happy,” he said.
Housing advocates said Bloomberg is correct that a growing city is a
good thing — but that the mayor largely was missing the point.
PHOTOS: BEST OF BROOKLYN: QUIRKY, COOL REAL ESTATE
“It is better to have the problem of a city that’s growing than a city
that’s shrinking,” said Benjamin Dulchin, executive director of the
Association of Neighborhood and Housing Developers in New York City.
But, he added, “The rezoning this administration has done to encourage
development is largely market-rate housing. There’s a lot of building
going on, but it is not necessarily what our population needs.”
Peter Carroll/GETTY IMAGES
The lack of affordability reflects demand. Above, Trump International Hotel and Towers at Columbus Circle.
RELATED: BLOOMBERG ADMINISTRATION SIGNED OFF ON CITYTIME EXPENSES: LAWYERS
Craig Gurian, of the Anti-Discrimination Center in New York City, which
lobbies for affordable housing, said median monthly gross rents in the
city rose 8.5% from 2007 to 2011 while median household income fell
6.8%, making it harder for New Yorkers to stay in their homes.
“The affordable housing crisis has gotten worse on his watch. He’s
literally out of touch. He doesn’t experience what most people in the
city are experiencing, which is a much greater sense of insecurity than
they felt 12 years ago,” Gurian said.
RELATED: PARK AVE. NOT IN NAME ONLY
“New Yorkers are spending more of their income on housing than ever,”
he added. “The mayor’s idea of how to measure progress on this issue is
wrong.”
Some politicians joined in the criticism.
RELATED: STEPHEN COLBERT POKES FUN DURING AL SMITH DINNER
Spencer Platt/Getty Images
Advocates slammed Bloomberg
for being insensitive toward New Yorkers being squeezed out of their
homes by rising rents. Above, a high rise on the far West Side of
Manhattan.
“This is part of what ... has made people hungry for change,” said City
Councilman Brad Lander (D-Brooklyn). “People want to see empathy from
their mayor.”
A Bloomberg spokesman pointed out that the mayor acknowledged that
there is a problem, and defended the administration’s record on
affordable housing.
“He is stating the reason for the problem, and acknowledging the
problem in both his words and in action, with the largest affordable
housing program in the country and by investing in our public housing
while the feds have cut off funding and other cities have walked away
from public housing,” said Marc LaVorgna, the spokesman.
“Our problem here is what he said: people want to live here — so the
demand is intense. Cities like Detroit or Camden, New Jersey, have
plenty of low-cost housing available — not because of some commitment to
affordability, but because there is no comparable demand to live in
those places. You prefer to have our problem over theirs.”
BLOOMBERG'S BLUSTER
Mayor Bloomberg has never been shy about his opinions. In his final months in office, he's showing no sign of slowing down.
On Billionaires: "If we could get every billionaire around the world to move here, it would be a godsend."
On Bill de Blasio: "De Blasio is running a 'class-warfare and racist' campaign.'"
On School Overcrowding: "It's a problem that's a very serious problem, but it's a nice problem to have that our kids want to go to school."
THEY WANT TO STEAL A NEIGHBORHOOD JEWEL
The Parks Dept. plans to destroy the Putnam Nature Trail, a unique wetland nature habitat in Van Cortlandt Park near Broadway, by turning it into a wide asphalt bike speedway. The Trail allows working people and local school groups to get close to hawks, herons, muskrats, frogs, turtles and other creatures. It is used by strollers, joggers, and runners — especially older users who prize its soft surface — as well as bicyclists.
The paving plan will remove hundreds of trees and surrounding undergrowth. These provide a cooling canopy to trail users and shelter and food for animals. Speeding bicycles will chase away the wildlife, making the road useless for nature observing and unsafe for walkers and runners of all ages.
The Parks Dept. calls this “multi-use access.” They say there are no funds to repair and maintain the Trail with crushed gravel that would make the Trail ACCESSIBLE FOR ALL USERS. So how would they maintain asphalt? They refuse to rule out bike rental kiosks (Citibank?) on their “Putnam Road.”
DEFEND OUR PARKS AND PUBLIC SERVICES!
Across the City and across society, corporations are being given pieces of parks and other open spaces such as Flushing Meadows and Jamaica Bay because there are supposedly “no funds.” Public schools are replaced by charters, the open areas in NYC Housing projects are being privatized for luxury housing, and the Post Office is under threat of privatizing.
It’s time to say NO to the defunding and privatization of public services. The Putnam Trail fight represents the environmental rights of working people, our right to nature, and our right to publicly-funded services. Let public officials know we will defend these rights!
DEMONSTRATE
PUBLIC FUNDING FOR NATURE AREAS: NO PRIVATIZATION
Wed., Oct. 23, 6:30 PM, Community Bd. 8
Van Cortlandt Park South at Bailey Ave.
RALLY
PUTNAM TRAIL: SAVE IT, DON’T PAVE IT!
Sun., Oct. 27, 1 PM, Broadway at 250th.
To help build these actions contact: freeds@lycos.com OR PutnamTrailRally@gmail.com
THEY WANT TO STEAL A NEIGHBORHOOD JEWEL
The Parks Dept. plans to destroy the Putnam Nature Trail, a unique wetland nature habitat in Van Cortlandt Park near Broadway, by turning it into a wide asphalt bike speedway. The Trail allows working people and local school groups to get close to hawks, herons, muskrats, frogs, turtles and other creatures. It is used by strollers, joggers, and runners — especially older users who prize its soft surface — as well as bicyclists.
The paving plan will remove hundreds of trees and surrounding undergrowth. These provide a cooling canopy to trail users and shelter and food for animals. Speeding bicycles will chase away the wildlife, making the road useless for nature observing and unsafe for walkers and runners of all ages.
The Parks Dept. calls this “multi-use access.” They say there are no funds to repair and maintain the Trail with crushed gravel that would make the Trail ACCESSIBLE FOR ALL USERS. So how would they maintain asphalt? They refuse to rule out bike rental kiosks (Citibank?) on their “Putnam Road.”
DEFEND OUR PARKS AND PUBLIC SERVICES!
Across the City and across society, corporations are being given pieces of parks and other open spaces such as Flushing Meadows and Jamaica Bay because there are supposedly “no funds.” Public schools are replaced by charters, the open areas in NYC Housing projects are being privatized for luxury housing, and the Post Office is under threat of privatizing.
It’s time to say NO to the defunding and privatization of public services. The Putnam Trail fight represents the environmental rights of working people, our right to nature, and our right to publicly-funded services. Let public officials know we will defend these rights!
DEMONSTRATE
PUBLIC FUNDING FOR NATURE AREAS: NO PRIVATIZATION
Wed., Oct. 23, 6:30 PM, Community Bd. 8
Van Cortlandt Park South at Bailey Ave.
RALLY
PUTNAM TRAIL: SAVE IT, DON’T PAVE IT!
Sun., Oct. 27, 1 PM, Broadway at 250th.
To help build these actions contact: freeds@lycos.com OR PutnamTrailRally@gmail.com