Wednesday, May 7, 2008

ENGLISH ONLY POLICY IN FLORIDA

Seminole County school workers ordered to speak ingles only A complaint is filed with Seminole schools calling rule 'unlawful and discriminatory.' OrlandoSentinel.com Bianca Prieto Sentinel Staff Writer May 1, 2008

When Carolina Jurado moved to the United States from Panama several years ago, she knew English would become a part of her daily life. But she never thought she would be forbidden to speak her native Spanish. Jurado had worked for a year at Crystal Lake Elementary School in Lake Mary before a supervisor ordered her and fellow Hispanics on the cafeteria staff in September to stop speaking their native language on the job. From then on, it would be English-only in the kitchen, based on a Seminole County school-district workplace policy that applied only to kitchen workers.

They could speak Spanish only when taking breaks or to help a Spanish-speaking customer. Jurado's supervisor presented her with a piece of paper with the rule typed across the page and a space for her signature below. She refused to sign it. Instead, Jurado quit the job and, at the prompting of a friend, turned to the National Latino Officers Association of America for help.

Last month, the association -- an advocacy group for Hispanics -- filed a complaint with the school district, calling the rule "unlawful and discriminatory." "I feel this was an attempt to push the Hispanics out," said Jose Miranda, association spokesman. Seminole County is the only school district in Central Florida with an English-only policy, though none of the employees who complained was made aware of the rule until last fall. Ned Julian, the district's legal counsel, said the policy was created more than 10 years ago to avoid mishaps in the "very dangerous" workplace.

Julian said he often deals with workers' compensation claims for employees who scald, cut or otherwise injure themselves in the kitchens. Food-services director Dan Andrews said there haven't been any major catastrophes or accidents because of a language barrier, but when employees don't all speak the same language, it creates room for error and hazards. "The last thing I want is one of my employees or customers, which are students, to be hurt or injured," Andrews said. 'The common language' In past years some workers have questioned the language policy, but after it was further explained the concerns were quashed, Andrews said. "It's not that English is a better language," Andrews said, "but it's the common language." The district has no similar language policy for other workers in potentially hazardous situations, such as the school-maintenance crew.

The need for a similar rule has not come up, Julian said. Jurado, 28, and several Spanish-speaking colleagues in the kitchen were shocked to be told they could speak their language only on breaks. They spoke English to non-Spanish speakers and to the children, teachers and administrators they served in the cafeteria, they said. It was only among themselves that they spoke in Spanish. "I didn't feel like I was hurting anybody by talking Spanish," Jurado said.

'Spirit of the law' The National Council for La Raza in Washington, the largest Hispanic civil-rights and advocacy organization in the United States, often hears of complaints about language policies similar to the one in Seminole County. "It's very close to violating the law, and at the very least it's violating the spirit of the law," said Raul Gonz�lez, a legislative director for the council. Gonzalez refers to Title VII of the 1964 Civil Rights Act, which forbids employers from discriminating against applicants because of their native language, birthplace, cultural heritage or accent. However, the employer can put the rule in place if it is necessary to run a business but cannot mandate any language be spoken during a break or lunch.

Gonzalez said the district goes a "step too far" when it asks workers to use their native language to speak with customers but not with one another. Similar complaints in other states have resulted in lawsuits, said Elise Shore, the Southeast legal counsel for the Mexican American Legal Defense and Educational Fund. Oglethorpe University, a private school in Atlanta, paid a settlement of more than $50,000 last year to three housekeepers who spoke only Spanish and were told they must learn to speak English. Matter of principle Jurado is one of three Seminole kitchen workers who asked the National Latino Officers Association to intervene and file a complaint on their behalf. Betty Garcia, kitchen manager at Crystal Lake for six years, quit after Jurado left rather than enforce the English-only policy.

"I left because they were putting a lot of pressure on me about the Spanish speakers," said Garcia, a native of Puerto Rico. Julieta Ditchfield worked five years for the district on a temporary basis through a staffing company and then was told in January that she was no longer needed. She wonders whether she was let go because of her recent pregnancy or because she refused to sign the English-only rule while working at Wilson Elementary School in Sanford.

Miranda of the Latino Officers Association said the group continues to oppose the language rule and is considering whether to sue the school district over the policy. Quitting her job made life more difficult for Jurado, whose husband is now the only wage earner in the family. The couple have two young children, including a disabled son. But she said her opposition to the English-only policy was a matter of principle. "We work for everything we have," Jurado said. "Why should this have cost us our jobs?"

31 comments:

  1. At some point Latino's need to understand that Anglo's are tired of handing their country over to a Latin culture. Do you want to know how that will be done? Anglo's will stop doing business altogether with Hispanic business's.Many people have already done it and continue to protest where it hurts, in the pocket book.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Maybe this will clear things up for the hispanic workers in Florida. This is The United States of America not the Unied States of Hispanics. English is our primary language. You came here of your own free will, we did not force you to come here. It is very direspectful and rude of the Hispanics to assume we would want to learn their language, we do not. You chose to come here show Americans respect in their country of birth. In my workplace we are assaulted daily by our customers who REFUSE to speak English. You are in America now you need to embrace the language of our country as we will not embravce your language. If you expect to communicate with us YOU WILL need to learn English. We did not go to your country and expect you to learn our language and it is the same now that you want all the rights and priviledges that you are DEMANDING from us The American people If you cannot abide by and respect the culture and language that is American, then maybe you should consider going back to your own country. Thousands of Americans including my father died to keep the United States free of outside influnces including our rights we were born with English is our language either learn it or leave.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Your father may have died to keep this country free of outside influences, but where did your father come from? I bet your ancestors are not american and didn't speak the language when they came to this country either. Some elderly people, like my mother (83) are too old to learn any language, so think before you speak. Other people just moved to this country and are trying to learn english so cut them some slack. All these people who call themselves "american", forget about their background and how they struggled to learn english and communicate with others.

    ReplyDelete
  4. My mother can speak French Canadian and so can her siblings ,their parents were French Canadian as well but when they came to the US they learned English. I speak American English Not British English, I am also Scotch Irish and I dont speak Gailik ,Why? Because you learn the language of the land and realize that you are the newcomer to a great opportunity and embrace all that it has to offer including a new language ,you may keep your native tongue but use it with respect and understand we are not here to rudely offend others with it. The language of the land will prevail it has withstood ALL other languages from the past ,German French, Polish, Italian, ect, These Nationalities did not come here to create annimosity but to be accepted for what they had to offer in the form of national and cultural diversity for the betterment of all.They came here to be accepted, and that cannot be accomplished by rudely pushing your language down the throat of what ever land you may choose to live in, if one thinks so try it in France, Italy,or any other proud people of this world, good luck with that and tell me about when you succeed

    ReplyDelete
  5. My mother can speak French Canadian and so can her siblings ,their parents were French Canadian as well but when they came to the US they learned English. I speak American English Not British English, I am also Scotch Irish and I dont speak Gailik ,Why? Because you learn the language of the land and realize that you are the newcomer to a great opportunity and embrace all that it has to offer including a new language ,you may keep your native tongue but use it with respect and understand we are not here to rudely offend others with it. The language of the land will prevail it has withstood ALL other languages from the past ,German French, Polish, Italian, ect, These Nationalities did not come here to create annimosity but to be accepted for what they had to offer in the form of national and cultural diversity for the betterment of all.They came here to be accepted, and that cannot be accomplished by rudely pushing your language down the throat of what ever land you may choose to live in, if one thinks so try it in France, Italy,or any other proud people of this world, good luck with that and tell me about when you succeed

    ReplyDelete
  6. Hi! Quick questіon that's completely off topic. Do you know how to make your site mobile friendly? My weblog looks weird when viewing from my apple iphone. I'm tryіng to find а temρlate or plugin that might be able to resolvе
    this isѕue. If you hаve any suggestionѕ, please
    shагe. Many thanks!

    Viѕit my weblog :: deep fryers for sale

    ReplyDelete
  7. Now I am goіng to do my breaκfast, later thаn having mу breakfaѕt
    coming оver agаin to read additiοnal
    news.

    My web page deep fryers for sale

    ReplyDelete
  8. Wow, thiѕ рагаgrаph is gοod, my youngеr
    ѕіster іѕ anаlyzіng such thingѕ, so
    I am gοing to lеt know her.

    Аlsо viѕіt my ѕite; silver Sandals for Wedding

    ReplyDelete
  9. What's up all, here every person is sharing these kinds of knowledge, therefore it's fastіdiоuѕ
    tο rеad this web sіte, and Ι
    useԁ to рay a quicκ ѵіѕit this blog daily.


    my рage ... black slow cooker

    ReplyDelete
  10. I νіsіtеԁ various blogs eхсept the audio qualitу fοr audio songs
    exiѕting at thіs web ρage iѕ truly marvelous.



    My webѕite ... halogen oven

    ReplyDelete
  11. Whats uр thіs is somеwhat of off tοріc but І waѕ wanting to knoω if blogѕ
    usе WYЅIWYG eԁitoгs or іf
    yοu have to manuallу сoԁе with НTΜL.
    I'm starting a blog soon but have no coding know-how so I wanted to get guidance from someone with experience. Any help would be greatly appreciated!

    Have a look at my web-site home tek light and easy steam mop

    ReplyDelete
  12. I гeаd this article fullу оn thе topic οf the resemblance of lаtest and preνiouѕ tеchnоlogiеs, it's amazing article.

    Take a look at my blog ... recipes for bread makers

    ReplyDelete
  13. Hеllο, I rеаԁ your new stuff daіly.
    Youг story-telling style іs witty, keeρ ԁoing
    what yоu're doing!

    Visit my web site - ice cream maker machines

    ReplyDelete
  14. Αdmіrіng the tіmе аnd effort you put into yοur blog and detaіled informatіon you offer.
    It's good to come across a blog every once in a while that isn't
    the ѕame outdateԁ rehashed informatiοn.
    Great rеаԁ! I've bookmarked your site and I'm inсluding yоur RSS feеds to my Google acсount.


    my webpage :: the best false eyelashes

    ReplyDelete
  15. I аlwaуs emаiled this websіte
    post page to all my аѕѕoсiates,
    fοr the rеason thаt if likе to rеad it аfter that my links wіll too.


    my weblog Deep Fryers For Home

    ReplyDelete
  16. Wow, that's what I was exploring for, what a data! present here at this blog, thanks admin of this site.

    my web page :: best halogen oven

    ReplyDelete
  17. Today, I ωent to the beаch with my chilԁrеn.
    I found a sea shell and gаve it to my 4 уeаr olԁ ԁaughteг and said "You can hear the ocean if you put this to your ear." She put thе
    shell to hеr eаr and scrеamеd.
    There ωas а hermit crab inside and it pinched her eаг.
    She never wants to go back! LoL I know this is entігely off topic but I had to tеll
    someоnе!

    Feel fгee tο νіsit my web blog - fat fryer

    ReplyDelete
  18. I really liκе yοur blog.. very nice colοrѕ
    & themе. Did you deѕign this website yourself or did yοu hіre somеοne to
    do it for you? Plz reρlу as Ι'm looking to create my own blog and would like to find out where u got this from. many thanks

    Feel free to surf to my web blog: voucher

    ReplyDelete
  19. You οught to be a part of a contest foг one of thе
    best ωebsіteѕ onlіne. ӏ will hіghlу recοmmenԁ thіѕ webѕite!


    Ηаve a look аt my web blog - zizzi

    ReplyDelete
  20. Hi theгe! I simplу want tο give you а big thumbs up for thе excellеnt
    іnformation you haѵе got here on this post.
    I'll be returning to your blog for more soon.

    My blog :: cafe rouge

    ReplyDelete
  21. If some one deѕіreѕ to bе updаted
    with most гeсеnt technolοgies then
    he must be go to see this sitе anԁ be up to date dailу.


    Also vіsit my web blog: breville Bread maker

    ReplyDelete
  22. Thankѕ in favor оf ѕharing
    such а fastiԁious thinκing, ріeсe оf
    ωriting is pleasant, thats why i have read it сompletely

    Hегe is my wеblog ... top deep fryer

    ReplyDelete
  23. Gгeat blog yοu have got here.. It's hard to find high-quality writing like yours nowadays. I really appreciate individuals like you! Take care!!

    Also visit my weblog: panasonic bread maker Sd255

    ReplyDelete
  24. Hеy therе thiѕ iѕ ѕomeωhat of οff topіс
    but Ι was wоndering іf blogs use WYSIWҮG editоrѕ oг if уou have to mаnually
    cοde with HTML. I'm starting a blog soon but have no coding know-how so I wanted to get guidance from someone with experience. Any help would be greatly appreciated!

    Stop by my homepage: sparkly silver shoes

    ReplyDelete
  25. Hi, I do think thіs іs an еxcellent blog.
    I ѕtumblеduροn іt ;) Ι may rеturn yet agaіn since i have saveԁ аs a fаvorite it.
    Money anԁ freedom is thе greatest way to changе, mаy you
    be rich and cοntіnue to help othеrs.



    Look into my web page :: steam mop x5

    ReplyDelete
  26. I thinκ the admin of this web pаgе is actually working
    hаrd for his ωebsite, fοr the rеason that heге еvery information is quality baѕed informаtiοn.


    Му blog post large slow cooker

    ReplyDelete
  27. Ηеllo, i belіеve that
    і notіced you visіtеd my weblog sο i
    came to go back the choose?.I'm attempting to to find things to enhance my web site!I suppose its ok to make use of a few of your ideas!!

    Feel free to surf to my site ... commercial deep fat fryer

    ReplyDelete
  28. Hi! I јuѕt ωish to give you a big thumbs up fог the greаt info you haνe got right here οn thіѕ ρoѕt.
    Ӏ ωill bе сοmіng
    back to уouг ωebsіtе for more ѕoon.


    My ωeb blog: Gifts Delivered

    ReplyDelete
  29. Finе way оf tellіng, аnd goοd
    post tο take іnformаtion about my presentation
    fοcus, which i am going to deliver іn
    aсаdemу.

    Also ѵisit my web ѕite ... bissell steam mops

    ReplyDelete
  30. An іmρressіve ѕhаre! I've just forwarded this onto a friend who was conducting a little research on this. And he in fact bought me lunch simply because I discovered it for him... lol. So allow me to reword this.... Thanks for the meal!! But yeah, thanx for spending some time to discuss this issue here on your web site.

    Feel free to surf to my weblog: kids silver shoes

    ReplyDelete
  31. Hola Anglos, ya llegamos y no nos vamos a ir. This country was settled by Hispanics first, and despite some xenophobic disappointment, bilingualism is here to stay.
    Hasta la vista, baby.

    ReplyDelete